The South Side, a crisp and refreshing cocktail made with gin, lemon juice, mint, and simple syrup, remains as enigmatic as it is enduring. Despite its straightforward composition, the drink’s origins are steeped in uncertainty and folklore.
Frequently cited in connection with Prohibition-era speakeasies, the South Side is often romantically linked to notorious gangster Al Capone and his Chicago associates. Another widely circulated account credits the cocktail’s popularity to the 21 Club in New York City, where it was reportedly the signature drink of the former speakeasy. However, neither of these stories withstands historical scrutiny.
According to research compiled by Eric Felten in The Oxford Companion to Spirits and Cocktails, the South Side likely traces its roots to the Southside Sportsman’s Club on Long Island, New York. Originally served as a variation of the Mint Julep at the exclusive club, the drink gained prominence through the club’s affluent patrons, who began requesting it at bars beyond the club’s confines.
The earliest documented appearance of the South Side dates back to 1917, in Hugo Ensslin’s Recipes for Mixed Drinks, predating both Prohibition and Capone’s rise to power. In the years that followed, the cocktail became associated with the leisurely lifestyle of country clubs and sporting circles.
Structurally, the South Side belongs to the sour cocktail family—a category that balances a base spirit with citrus and sweetener. This classic formula underpins a range of well-known drinks, including the Daiquiri, Gin Sour, and Tommy’s Margarita. The South Side distinguishes itself with the addition of mint, which enhances the botanical complexity of gin while adding a burst of herbal freshness.
The result is a cocktail that is at once balanced and invigorating—an ideal choice for a warm afternoon or an elegant gathering. Though its exact birthplace may remain disputed, the South Side’s appeal continues to endure, transcending its murky origins to earn a place among the timeless classics of mixology.
You Might Be Interested In:
