Merlot, often overshadowed by its more prominent Bordeaux counterpart Cabernet Sauvignon, is proving once again that it can deliver exceptional quality at accessible prices. Known for its soft, ripe fruit character and approachable structure, Merlot continues to charm consumers and critics alike, especially when it comes to value.
This year’s top Merlot picks highlight wines that not only offer strong critic scores but are also widely available in the U.S. — all priced under $30. Each entry is evaluated based on global average retail price and aggregated critic ratings.
1. Rodney Strong Merlot 2021 – $18
Leading the list is the 2021 Rodney Strong Merlot from Sonoma County, California. Founded in 1959 by former dancer Rodney Strong, the winery has been under the Klein family’s stewardship since 1989. With an aggregated score of 93 points and a price point of $18, this wine offers standout value and accessibility.
2. Chateau Souverain Merlot 2021 – $11
Chateau Souverain, rooted in Alexander Valley, began in 1944 and has since become a symbol of consistency and innovation. The 2021 vintage presents a dark, fruity, and polished profile with a 92-point rating — all for just $11.
3. Francis Ford Coppola Diamond Collection Merlot 2022 – $15
Produced by the Delicato Family Wines-owned Francis Ford Coppola Winery, this 2022 release combines fruit from California and Oregon. With a critic score of 92 points and priced at $15, it delivers cinematic flair at a bargain.
4. Frei Brothers Reserve Merlot 2022 – $18
A legacy brand in Sonoma since 1890, Frei Brothers has been owned by E & J Gallo since 1978. The 2022 Reserve Merlot offers rich character and a 92-point critic score for $18, maintaining its tradition of quality.
5. Peirano Estate The Heritage Collection Six Clones Merlot 2021 – $18
Located in Lodi, Peirano Estate has been family-run since its establishment in 1881 by Italian immigrant Giacomo Peirano. The 2021 Six Clones Merlot is a blend of heritage and craftsmanship, earning a 92-point score.
6. Big Flower Merlot 2021 – $23
This South African entry comes from Stellenbosch’s Protea Heights, under Botanica Wines. Honoring the region’s first commercial flower farm, the 2021 Big Flower Merlot combines Bordeaux tradition with South African terroir. It scores 92 points and costs $23.
7. McManis Family Vineyards Merlot 2022 – $12
Operating out of California’s Central Valley, McManis Family Vineyards has been committed to “quality wine at an honest price” since 1990. The 2022 Merlot continues that mission, earning a 92-point score and priced at just $12.
8. Ferrari-Carano Merlot 2022 – $23
Founded in 1979 and now under Foley Family Wines, Ferrari-Carano has become a Sonoma Valley staple. The 2022 Merlot, with its elegant structure and 92-point rating, sells for $23.
9. Oberon Merlot 2022 – $27
Crafted by Napa Valley native Tony Coltrin, the 2022 Oberon Merlot showcases the region’s winemaking heritage. With a score of 92 points and a $27 price tag, it brings both tradition and finesse.
10. Chelsea Goldschmidt Guidestone Rise Merlot 2022 – $24
The final entry hails from Alexander Valley’s Goldschmidt Vineyards, founded by New Zealanders Nick and Yolyn Goldschmidt. Named for their daughter, the Chelsea Goldschmidt Merlot achieves a 92-point score and retails for $24.
Conclusion
This all-American (with one South African exception) collection showcases how Merlot continues to deliver remarkable quality without exceeding the $30 mark. With scores of 92 or higher and nationwide availability, these wines exemplify the intersection of accessibility, craftsmanship, and value in today’s wine market.
You Might Be Interested In:
